Black, pink and orange moulds in mushroom grows
Is any colour of mould okay to leave?
No colour on that list is a sign of healthy growth. Mould colour comes from its spores. Wikipedia says "the dust-like, colored appearance of molds is due to the formation of spores"1. So colour usually means the mould has matured and is now spreading.
The real question is whether you can name a mould by colour. Mostly you can't. The sources below show why.
What do pink, grey and yellow moulds look like?
A Penn State Extension guide describes a farm disease called cobweb. It has "weft-cotton-like mycelium (usually white; sometimes gray, pink, or yellow)" that can cover the casing, mushrooms and pins2. Casing is the soil-like layer put on top of some crops, and pins are the first tiny mushrooms.
The same guide describes bush, bread or barber mould as "bushy, hairlike mold" that is "usually white, turning gray or yellow"2. The guide lists cobweb with "flesh-colored spots" and bush, bread or barber mould with "light flesh-colored spots"2. They aren't described as identical.
Notice the overlap. White, grey and yellow turn up in both. A colour alone won't tell you which one is on your grow.
What about black mould?
Black moulds exist, and they're easy to mix up. Wikipedia says Aspergillus niger is "a common contaminant of food", and that "its black colonies can be confused with those of Stachybotrys", which is another black mould3. If experts say two black moulds can be confused, a home grower won't sort them by eye either.
Is there an orange one?
The saved sources don't describe an orange mould in a mushroom grow, so I won't tell you what one looks like or means. Orange, pink or any odd colour is still a reason to stop and treat the grow as contaminated.
Do they all mean the same thing?
For what you do next, yes. A coloured, powdery or fuzzy patch that isn't your mushroom's own white growth means something else is competing for the food. Moulds spread by spores. Penn State warns that cobweb spores "are readily distributed in air currents and by watering" and that very little air movement is needed2.
That's a farm warning, but the idea carries over. Opening a mouldy bag indoors, or spraying water on it, can throw spores around. Mould spores are already a common part of household dust1, and you don't want to add to them.
So don't poke at it, don't sniff it up close and don't water it. Next, work out whether to bin the grow and how to clean up afterwards. If you aren't sure whether you're looking at mould or mycelium, start with telling mould from mycelium.
Notes and sources
- Mold, Wikipedia
- Basic IPM Practices for Organic Mushroom Farms - Fungal Diseases of Mushrooms, Penn State Extension
- Aspergillus niger, Wikipedia